The condition of 17 city-owned bridges was the subject of a press conference held by mayoral candidate Michael Villa on Tuesday on the Prospect St. bridge in Amsterdam. At the conference, Villa cited a recent report from the NY State Department of Transportation that shows that nine of the 17 city-owned bridges are considered “deficient,” two are listed as “structurally deficient” and six are listed as “functionally obsolete.” 15 other bridges in the city are owned and maintained by NY State.
However, according to the NYSDOT, none of these categorizations indicate that the bridges are unsafe to travel on.
Each bridge is rated by NY State on a scale from 1 to 7, with 7 being brand new. Bridges rated under 5 are considered “deficient” and require “corrective maintenance or rehabilitation.” A bridge is categorized as “structurally deficient” if it “typically requires significant maintenance and repair to remain in service and eventual rehabilitation or replacement to address deficiencies.”
The term “functionally obsolete” is not based on a bridge’s structural condition, but on features of the bridge such as its lane width, shoulders, and clearance.
Eight bridges have ratings of five or above. The city’s highest rated bridge was built in 2003 on Fourth Ave. and has a near perfect score of 6.44, but is still listed as “functionally obsolete.”
“Amsterdam has 17 bridges that are in deplorable shape,” said Villa. “Our bridge infrastructure needs real attention.”
In a written statement issued at the conference, Villa said “All of our 17 city-owned bridges are in urgent need of maintenance and repairs, but Ann Thane is focused on spending $1 million on aesthetic work on the Mohawk Valley Pedestrian Bridge.”
In June, State Assemblyman Angelo Santabarbara announced a $1 million grant from NY State for the city to complete historic markers, engravings, and other artistic additions to the pedestrian bridge.
While Villa said the pedestrian bridge is a “good thing,” he said the project is an example of the city “putting it’s wants before it’s needs.”
“Our city should be working with state representatives on infrastructure projects that are going to matter and are going to relate to our entire city,” said Villa. “It’s the mayor’s responsibility to set that priority. As your mayor, the priorities of this administration, if elected, would be to put public safety, our crumbling infrastructure, and the blight that dots our neighborhoods at the top of the list.”
Reached for comment on Wednesday, City Engineer Rich Miller said that except for one recent issue found on the Guy Park Ave. Extension bridge, currently “there’s no issues with any of the bridges that I know of.”
He said his department regularly takes care of maintenance issues on the city’s bridges that are discovered by state inspections. He noted that because the state only inspects bridges every two years, the current report may not reflect recent repairs.
As an example, he pointed out the bridge on Main St., which was last inspected on 9/24/2014 and is listed as “structurally deficient” had already been repaired.
Miller also explained the categorization of “functionally obsolete.”
“What that means, if you take a design that is produced today, it will have two 12 foot lanes, 3 foot shoulders, sidewalks and guard rails on both sides. You go look at the bridges that are rated here as functionally obsolete, you will find they are missing one or the other. Either they are missing a sidewalk, might be missing shoulders, the lanes might be 10 feet instead of 12. That, [according to NY State] is stated as functionally obsolete. There’s nothing…wrong with the bridge.”
According to Miller, the Fourth Ave. bridge, which is one of the city’s newest bridges, is listed as “functionally obsolete” only because it has one sidewalk instead of two.
Summary of the conditions of city-owned bridges according to NYSDOT as of 8/31/2015
|Road||Status||Condition Rating||Date of last inspection|
|Federal St. Ext||FO||5.00||10/9/13|
|Guy Park Ave Ext||N||4.84||6/18/13|
SD=Structurally deficient, FO=Functionally obsolete, N = Neither SD or FO
Jay Towne and Tim Becker both contributed to this article.